Marian Bustin’s Deportation Investigation
Posted by Admin.March 24th, 2026
By Abigail Moncus, West Virginia Feminist Activist Collection Project Archivist
In the National Organization for Women, West Virginia and Morgantown Chapters Records, a wide range of materials document the activities and functions of NOW in West Virginia. Most relate to the internal functions of the various chapters and their productive outputs, including meeting minutes, newsletters and various ephemera. However, the collection also contains occasional instances of material created by other organizations operating in the Morgantown area, such as a pamphlet created by the local Socialist Workers Party expressing support for coal miner Marian Bustin, who was facing deportation for her socialist activities.

While living in Morgantown, West Virginia, and working in Republic Steel Kitt No. 1 Mine, Bustin came to the attention of authorities in late 1980 when the United States Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) and Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) attempted to deport her for her membership in the Socialist Workers Party (SWP) and Young Socialist Alliance (YSA).
Marian Bustin, born Marian Margaret Carr to a working-class family in Scotland in 1954, was active in social activism from an early age. She reported participating in Glasgow’s Women in Action and Indo-China Committee, as well as England’s International Marxist Group.1
While visiting the United States from June 1974 to January 1975, Bustin (then Blackburn, after her first husband) maintained membership with the Lower Manhattan Branch of the Socialist Workers Party in New York and reportedlyattended “six SWP-related meetings.”2
After returning to Scotland, she married American citizen Andrew Bustin and moved permanently to the United States, first to New York, and later to Morgantown, West Virginia, following her separation from her second husband. Unbeknownst to Marian Bustin, at the time of her residential move to the U.S. in 1977, the U.S. embassy in London reported her as a socialist to the INS, leading the New York INS office to open an investigation.
This investigation followed her to Morgantown, where the INS coordinated with the Pittsburgh FBI and West Virginia State Police for any updates on her case. In early 1979, she became aware of this investigation when INS inspector Godfrey England reported to her that her “permanent resident status was in danger due to reports that she had attended meetings of the SWP in 1974 and 1975.”3
Her case gained public attention in 1980 after lawyers of the SWP and YSA obtained her INS and FBI files while working on a lawsuit against the U.S. government. At the time, she was a member of United Mine Workers Local 2095 and active with the Morgantown chapter of the Coalition Against Registration and the Draft.
Bustin’s case was quickly taken on by the Morgantown SWP and YSA. On Oct. 31, 1980, Bustin made her first appearance in a press conference alongside Tom Moriarty, the 1980 Socialist Workers candidate for West Virginia governor, criticizing the government campaign against her, which aired on WCHS, WCAW radio, and WCHS-TV.4

A flyer promoting a rally supporting Marian Bustin in Morgantown, 1980 November (Government Harassment Rally, undated, Box 2, Folder 54, National Organization for Women, West Virginia and Morgantown Chapters, Records, A&M 3247, West Virginia and Regional History Center, West Virginia University Libraries, Morgantown, West Virginia.)
A campaign was also launched in her defense. The first rally took place Nov. 11, 1980, at the former Pathfinder Bookstore at 957 University Ave. in Morgantown. Speakers included Bustin and Moriarty, along with Larry Seigle, a national committee member of the Socialist Workers Party, and Hector Marroquin, a fellow party member also facing deportation threats.

Another rally was held Feb. 28, 1981. Speakers included Bustin, YSA secretary Katherine Crowder, civil rights attorney Franklin Cleckley, Morgantown attorney Robert Bastress, Sandinista National Liberation Front member Carlos Sanchez, and Morgantown ACLU director Trudy Herod.
The pamphlet mentioned earlier in this article likely entered the NOW records after Bustin attended a Morgantown NOW meeting to promote this 1981 rally. Misidentified as “Maureen Buston,” she spoke at this meeting, but NOW members did not take action on sending a speaker to the rally.

In April 1981, Bustin and Marroquin testified about the deportation threats in the Socialist Workers Party v. Attorney General of the United States.5 After several years, the SWP was awarded $264,000 in damages relating to disruptive activities, surreptitious entries, and the use of informants.6
In the months following public exposure of her case, Bustin traveled as a speaker for the Political Rights Defund Fund, visiting Wisconsin, New York, Pennsylvania, Illinois, and southern West Virginia. As attention on her case died down, she presumably returned to her normal activities.
In the following years, she continued her socialist activitism, writing several articles for The Militant, including “District 17 miners rally to protest nonunion coal” (May 29, 1981), “Miners speak about safety cuts” (March 26, 1982), “Toledo abortion clinic bombed” (July 13, 1986), and “Toledo rally protests abortion-clinic bombing” (July 18, 1986).
Tracing Bustin’s life after the 1980s is difficult due to her limited public presence. However, available evidence suggests she relocated to Ohio before 1986, and later to Iowa around 1988, based on occasional references in The Militant. She appears to have continued a career working in various labor jobs.
The lack of reporting on her case suggests she was never deported.
Materials regarding Marian Bustin and other related activities can be found in the National Organization for Women Records at the West Virginia and Regional History Center.

This project is made possible with support from the National Historic Publications and Records Commission.
References:
1. Vivian Sahner, “The story of Marian Bustin,” The Militant 44, No. 42 (1980): 12.
2. Investigative Summary, 1974, Box 2, Folder 57, National Organization for Women, West Virginia and Morgantown Chapter, Records, A&M 3247, West Virginia and Regional History Center, West Virginia University Libraries, Morgantown, West Virginia.
3. Vivian Sahner, “Gov’t threatens to deport socialist miner,” The Militant 44, No. 39 (1980): 6.
4. “Radio, TV cover Bustin case,” The Militant 44, No. 42 (1980): 12.
5. Vivian Sahner, “Trail witnesses to document gov’t harassment,” The Militant 45, No. 12 (1981): 3.
6. Socialist Workers Party v. Attorney General of the United States, 642 F.Supp. 1357 (S.D.N.Y.1986).


















































































